Loading Publication...
close
 
Las Cienegas National Conservation Area south of Tucson, Arizona. A 90,000 acre intact grassland, home of the historic Empire Ranch, that is now owned and managed by the Bureau of Land Management. The Conservancy and several partners are leading an adaptive management program that monitors and makes management changes based on observations of grassland health.

Las Ciénegas Adaptive Management

We are collaborating with the Bureau of Land Management to combine a strong monitoring & data analysis program with BLM’s decision-making processes to ensure managers at Las Ciénegas National Conservation Area have current and reliable information to inform management actions.

Why is Las Ciénegas NCA important?

Las Ciénegas NCA supports 5 of the rarest habitat types in the American Southwest: cottonwood-willow riparian forest, ciénega marshland, sacaton grass floodplain, mesquite bosque, and semidesert grassland. It is home to 6 endangered species and has 2 eligible wild and scenic river segments. The NCA’s intact grassland, stream, riparian, and marsh habitat are the best remaining examples of ecosystems that were historically more common in southeastern Arizona. The NCA also supports a livestock grazing operation.

Located in southeastern Arizona, the 45,000-acre National Conservation Area is part of BLM’s National Landscape Conservation System.

The State of Las Ciénegas NCA

The Nature Conservancy began working with BLM at Las Ciénegas in 2004 to develop a “State of the NCA” report. To prepare the report we analyzed existing data and monitoring protocols for the NCA’s grasslands and watershed, riparian forest, aquatic habitat, and select special status species. We also tested and recommended alternative monitoring protocols to improve BLM’s ability to detect change without increasing the cost of monitoring. An additional report describes BLM’s Biological Planning Process. It illustrates how BLM, with input from the grazing permittee and advisory teams, is using monitoring data to make grazing management decisions.

What is adaptive management?

Providing timely information on natural resources

Adaptive management is designed to take the guess work out of the management of our natural resources. A science-based adaptive management and monitoring program provides decision-makers with reliable and timely information on the condition and trend of resources. Combined with research studies, adaptive management helps us understand why ecosystem conditions or species’ populations change.

Combining scientific monitoring with decision making

Adaptive management is more than science, however. If a land manager’s decision-making processes and timeframes are not explicit, or data are not analyzed in a timely manner, decision-making and the state of our resources are likely to suffer. Adaptive management is really a process of coupling effective scientific monitoring with decision-making.

Applying adaptive management at Las Ciénegas

At Las Ciénegas, BLM has been working with resource advisory teams to

  • implement a focused and effective monitoring program
  • coordinate and review monitoring results, and
  • ensure that the science and review steps are completed in a timely manner to facilitate BLM decisions on management activities.

Management steps at Las Ciénegas

At Las Ciénegas, BLM is continually implementing the 6 primary steps in adaptive management

  1. Identification of management goals and measurable thresholds in resource condition.
  2. Development of a monitoring protocol with adequate sampling effort to detect biologically meaningful change in resource condition over a specified time period and an optimal frequency and timeframe during which monitoring should be conducted.
  3. Consistent implementation of the monitoring protocol and analysis of data.
  4. Timely review of data against established goals and thresholds to determine the need for changes in management.
  5. Implementation of needed management changes (and continued monitoring).
  6. Implementation of follow-up scientific studies to fill identified information gaps.
Related Research
Sep 2016
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Grassland
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
G.S. Bodner and M.D. Robles
Enduring a decade of drought: Patterns and drivers of vegetation change in a semi-arid grassland
This study used a long-term dataset to examine the impacts of drought on grassland conditions at Las Cienegas National Conservation Area in southeastern Arizona from 2004-2014. Changes included declines in perennial grass basal cover with patchy mortality, leaf litter increases, shrub declines and i[...]
Dec 2013
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
Riparian-aquatic
Caves, J., G. Bodner, K. Simms, L. Fisher, and T. Robertson
Integrating Collaboration, Adaptive Management, and Scenario-Planning: Experiences at Las Cienegas
Part of the Ecology and Society journal’s special issue on adaptive management, this paper summarizes the essential lessons learned from 15 years’ of collaboration and strong commitment from public stakeholders at Las Cienegas National Conservation Area in southeastern Arizona.  The paper desc[...]
Oct 2012
Papers
Arizona
BLM, NGO
Grassland, Riparian-aquatic
Grassland Assessment
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
Tiller, R., M. Hughes, and G. Bodner
Sacaton Riparian Grasslands: Mapping Distribution and Ecological Condition
Riparian grasslands dominated by big sacaton (Sporobolus wrightii) once covered floodplains across the southwest, but have been reduced to some 5% of their historical extent. Sacaton stands that remain provide key resources for watershed function, wildlife, and livestock—yet may need special manag[...]
Jun 2009
Papers
Grassland
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
Bodner, G.
Grasses of Las Cienegas National Conservation Area
This user-friendly field guide can help people of all skill levels identify 50 native and exotic perennial grasses, plus several annual species. This guide grew out of citizen science involvement tracking grassland health at the Las Cienegas National Conservation Area in southeastern Arizona. Some s[...]
Jul 2005
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Grassland
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management, Livestock Management
Gori, D., and Schussman, H.
State of the Las Ciénegas National Conservation Area, Part I
Summarizes work completed to assist the Bureau of Land Management in the development and implementation of a science-based adaptive management and monitoring program to evaluate progress toward objectives established in BLM’s Resource Management Plan. Includes 1) an analysis of data collected betw[...]
Jul 2007
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
Riparian-aquatic
Bodner, G., K. Simms, and D. Gori
State of the Las Ciénegas NCA, Part II: Gila Topminnow Population Status and Trends
This study analyzed 15 years of data on the endangered Gila topminnow (Poeciliopsis occidentalis occidentalis) to determine the population status and trend at Las Cienegas. We also tested alternative monitoring protocol to provide managers with more timely and reliable information on topminnow popul[...]
Feb 2008
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management
Riparian-aquatic
Bodner, G., and K. Simms
State of the Las Ciénegas NCA, Part III: Condition of Riparian Habitats and Channel Geomorphology
Presents information on the condition of riparian habitats and compares these with objectives established in BLM’s Resource Management Plan. Includes 1) an analysis of data collected between 1990 and 2006 on the condition of the NCA’s riparian forests and stream channel geomorphology, 2) an ecol[...]
May 2006
Papers
Arizona
BLM
Grassland
Las Cienegas Adaptive Management, Livestock Management
Simms, K., G. Drennen, B. Cooper, G. Bodner, and D. Gori
Report on the Biological Planning Process for Livestock Management at Las Ciénegas
Jointly authored by BLM and TNC, this report summarizes the monitoring information used and decision-making process for the 2005-2006 grazing plan at Las Ciénegas National Conservation Area. The report details how BLM, with input from partners, advisory teams, and the grazing permittee, are using u[...]
Grassland Assessment
Feb 2010
Maps
Grassland
Grassland Assessment
Dan Majka
Grassland Assessment
This map shows a generalized view of grasslands in Arizona, southeastern New Mexico, and northern Sonora, Mexico. The map uses GIS data from our grasslands assessment, the result of a two-year study to delineate grasslands and their ecological condition.[...]